Posted by admin on 09 10th, 2010 | no responses

The San Bruno gas fire and the futility of harping on fossil-fuel disasters

by Jonathan Hiskes. An explosion from a ruptured natural-gas line killed at least four people and destroyed an entire city block in the San Francisco suburb of San Bruno on Thursday night. Also on Thursday, a pipeline burst in a Romeoville, Ill., industrial park and is still spewing oil. It’s from same Canadian oil company that spilled more than 800,000 gallons of tar sands crude oil into a Michigan creek this summer. And of course the slow cleanup from the BP rig blowout continues in the Gulf of Mexico. That mishap, in turn, overshadowed the Massey Energy coal-mine explosion that killed 29 workers, and the coal freighter that crashed into the Great Barrier Reef on a shortcut back to China earlier this year. The costs of these disasters — human, ecological, and economic — are clear enough. And the costs are still sky-high when these projects go right — when coal, oil, and gas are safely extracted and burned and their heat-trapping pollutants sent into the atmosphere (as The Onion described so well). But harping and nagging and saying “See how bad fossil fuels are” doesn’t really get us anywhere. Here’s why: People already know that our dependence on dirty energy is a problem. They get it. There’s even an appetite for a national clean-energy strategy/program — it’s just not overwhelming enough to overcome the undemocratic dynamics of the Senate . So why aren’t we sufficiently riled up to change the situation? One of the more persuasive theories is status quo bias . Psychologists find that when people are anxious (and nothing breeds anxiety like a recession), they cling to what they know, even if it’s clearly problematic. Our fossil-fuel economy may be gasping, sputtering, and occasionally blowing up homes, but at least it’s the devil we know, not some mysterious cleantech network of solar panels and smart meters and compact neighborhoods. People don’t need hectoring told-you-so’s.

More on SKCEA.org:

  • European Airlines provide early data on carbon emissions, show slight reduction
    Airlines operating in and out of European airports have complied with the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) and handed over data despite the refusal of carriers from China and India. The airlines have provided emission information ahead of the introduction of mandatory reporti...
  • EU Household Plastics Banning
    The European Union will ban six toxic chemicals within three to five years, three of which are commonly used in plastic household items. Among the compounds are three plastic softening phthalates, a musk fragrance, a flame retardant and a hardener for epoxy resin. Although the mo...
  • Wild Immunity
    Which is better to be? Wild and free or tame and domesticated? That has always been an interesting philosophical question. Professor Mark Viney and colleagues at the University of Bristol compared the immune function of wild mice who have to find their own food with that of mice ...
  • Join TDG Live Today at Abe’s Market, and Get Exclusive Cyber Monday Discounts on Green Gifts
    Tune in to a live stream to meet the inspiring producers of better goods. Then get more green gift ideas ....
  • Reclaiming a derelict site to create a community garden
    The story of how a group of dissatisfied residents pulled together, got funding, and created a blooming community garden where the work, and the rewards, are shared Not far from the 2012 Olympic Village in Stratford, another local regeneration project, albeit on a much smaller sc...

Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word